Only hope that all humans shall might be saved 2 Peter 3:9, 1 Tm. by the following words: “I have loved them as you have loved me” [Jn 17.23]. In short, God is infinitely good and can only create good. One is united to God by having faith in Him and becoming sanctified through “participation” in the Christian life. [Morwenna Ludlow; Oxford University Press.] For one, Gregory’s treatise is hardly “bold” in its approach to universalism because it never even talks about universalism. The implication is that if every knee will bow, then there must be a “restitution of all things” (i.e. This is important, because this is the context behind him giving an exegesis of the Rich Man and Lazarus. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Estranging ourselves from evil in this way brings about our salvation. We must immerse ourselves in, the Christian life to come to know God. The divine, pure goodness will contain in itself every nature endowed with reason; nothing made by God is excluded from his kingdom, once everything mixed with some elements of base material has been con, d by refinement in fire. In, ul mentions this in his Epistle to the Romans: “For if we have been enemies, we have been re, conciled to God” [Rom 5.10]. The Greek … How can this be confused with universalism? is that of Christians and not all human beings: In the last of his words [above], Paul plainly speaks of the nonexistence (anuparktos) of evil by stating that God is in all things and pr, ll truly be in all things when no evil will be found, . the Son’s body. Gregory writes somewhere around the middle: What therefore does Paul teach us? The primary purpose of this paper is to demonstrate that St. Gregory of Nyssa was a proponent of the doctrine of universal restoration and believed that it was truly a Christian doctrine established in Scripture. Thus, the Father who loves his own Son loves the Son’s body just as the Son himself. "By the days of Gregory of Nyssa it (Universalism), aided by the unrivaled learning, genius and piety of Origen, had prevailed, and had succeeded in leavening, not the East alone, but much of the West. In his continued parsing of “subjection” he writes as follows: Paul mentions this in his Epistle to the Romans: “For if we have been enemies, we have been reconciled to God” [Rom 5.10]. I am confident that, when read as a whole (and in con, text), the universalist exegesis does not appear simply foolish, But, what we have just seen is that the experts have ham-handed an extremely, and Roman Catholicism, they do not understand Gregory, andid presumption that those reading would understand that we are saved by a, nergy and this salvation is a sanctifying process, universalism in this work, that does not mean he does not teach it elsewhere. ( Log Out / In so doing, this implicitly equates the teaching found in the following parable with his doctrine on universal restoration: …it is impossible to make the framework of the narrative correspond with the truth, if we understand it literally; we can do that only by translating each detail into an equivalent in the world of ideas. He is atoned for all mankind. gregory of nyssa universalism. Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. If, then whether by forethought here, or by purgation hereafter, our soul becomes free from any emotional connection with the brute creation, there will be nothing to impede its contemplation of the Beautiful; for this last is essentially capable of attracting in a certain way every being that looks towards it. “For as in Adam all die, so also in Christ shall all be made alive, .” But each in his own order: Christ the first fruits, then, ory is speaking of Christians, not the universal salvation of M. thras worshippers, Hindus, Buddhists, and whatever else. Or something else? Archived. The preceding is very clear. After speculating about the soul and the passions, the work begins to speculate about how “every knee shall bow” and every tongue confess Jesus Christ. Because of this, Christ is named Lord by Paul, as mediator between God and man [1 Tim 2.5]. “Aha!,” says the universalist. Like his older brother, he opted at first for a secular career in rhetoric. The person who is divinized is explicitly “in Christ” and has “separated himself from sin” and in so doing “denied in himself the power of death” like Saint Paul. The story makes the sensual pleasure-loving man, when he sees that his own case is one that admits of no escape. Lastly, just because Gregory does not teach universalism in this work, that does not mean he does not teach it elsewhere. He who is in the Father. salvific nature of Christ’s incarnation, death, and resurrection. It completely destroys death, having earlier removed sin which, as it is said, held dominion over all mankind. In this way **evil will ****completely**** disappear**, when all are recalled to life through the resurrection: the righteous will immediately be transported to celestial bliss, while those held in the grip of sins will be consigned to the fire of Gehenna. Further proof of this is that Gregory, in what immediately follows, refers to Christians as “enemies” again: When all enemies have become God’s footstool, they will receive a trace of divinity in themselves. This is shown by Paul saying, “Death will be destroyed,” a clear statement that the power of evil will be utterly removed: persons are called enemies of God by disobedience, while those who have become the Lord’s friends are persuaded by Paul saying, “We are ambassadors for Christ, as though God did beseech you by us: ‘Be reconciled to God [2 Cor 6.20] . Get this from a library! I wanted to show that I was twisting nothing out of context. Christians) from earlier in this paragraph and the one preceding it. Christ unites all mankind to himself, and to the Father through himself. One body has been formed with the good as predominant; our body’s entire nature is united to the divine, pure nature. His argument consists in 1) the nature of God, 2) the nature of evil, which is non-Being or nothingness. Gregory died around AD 395 and is still revered as one of the greatest of the early Church Fathers. Once the entire kingdom is gathered to himself, Christ hands it over to God and the Father who unites everything to himself. Universalism. However, “it is necessary for him to reign, until he places his enemies under his feet.” We reverently take this, I believe, as Christ valiantly holding sway in his power. In the next paragraph, Gregory makes this even more explicit: Christ eternally builds himself up by those who join themselves to him in faith. Universal salvation : eschatology in the thought of Gregory of Nyssa and Karl Rahner. (The Greek Anthology, book I … We will see this be elaborated as the book unfolds. Rather, he appears to be teaching that a non-descript number of people are purged of sins and God annihilates all evil in this sense. Please bless the Moscow Patriarchate's missionary efforts in Cambodia to bring the Gospel to a people who have not heard it! North American universalism was active and organized. Therefore, the sense of Paul’s words becomes clear – the Son’s subjection to his Father signifies that he knows our entire human nature and has become its salvation. Paul looked to the true good al. Unity then means to be one body with him as Paul states, for all who are joined to the one body of Christ by participation are one body with him. Purgatorial Universalism was the belief of some of the early church fathers, especially Greek-speaking ones such as Clement of Alexandria, Origen, and Gregory of Nyssa. This is often due to the lack of systematic structure and the presence of terminological inconsistencies i… For as salvation is brought near to us by sub, Being reconciled, we shall be saved in this life” [Rom. It is fascinating how much ground the early Church shares with Plato and the Greek philosophers, and yet how much of Greek philosophy is rejected or corrected. The salvation of Paul i, ent, place their faith in Christ, and liv, varying meanings. However, we are separated from evil for no other reason than for being united to God through subjection. But while the latter proceeded, on the subject of the soul, as far in the direction of supposed consequences as the thinker pleased, we are not entitled to such licence, I mean that of affirming what we please; we make the Holy Scriptures the rule and the measure of every tenet; we necessarily fix our eyes upon that, and approve that alone which may be made to harmonize with the intention of those writings…we will adopt, as the guide of our reasoning, the Scripture, which lays it down as an axiom that there is no excellence in the soul which is not a property as well of the Divine nature…we will speak upon these points by making our study of them so far as we can follow the chain of Scriptural tradition. Thus, for God to be our food, it is proper to understand him as being eaten; the same applies to drink, clothing, shelter, air, location, wealth, enjoyment, beauty, health, strength, prudence, glory, blessedness and anything else judged good which our human nature needs. This requires a long slog through all his works, one I will partake in by the grace of God, the prayers of Gregory, and I hope your own. This is a very basic and obvious point. But in the coming life, when mortality is at an end and immortality granted, and sin has no longer any place, God will be all in all. In speaking of this purgation, which we can agree from the above parable of the Rich Man and Lazarus is not applicable literally to every individual, the vagaries of language certainly give off an air of universalism. They discuss the soul, its nature and origin, and the resurrection. This is ironic given its own logical derivations and speculations: As… People popularly assume Gregory is a universalist because it is asserted so confidently and categorically. While the doctrine of annihilation has practically disappeared, Universalism has established itself, has become the prevailing opinion, even in quarters antagonistic to the school of Alexandria. Hindus are not being invoked here. Gregory of Nyssa on future punishment. Thus, the Father who loves his own Son loves the Son’s body just as the Son himself. No longer do any of our passions rule our [human] nature, since it is necessary that none of them dominate – all are subjected to the one who rules over all. It, hrist receives in himself all who are joined to him through the fellowship of. We must immerse ourselves in the Christian life to come to know God. I am confident that, when read as a whole (and in context), the universalist exegesis does not appear simply foolish—it appears completely inept. What we see here is nothing else than Gregory describing Theosis. We can see, God’s goodness pervades the sacraments and the good things of life so that He is “all things for us,” meaning the Christians. About "If one should ask what we are worshipping and adoring, the answer is ready: we are honouring love." This doctrine was explicitly taught by St. Gregory of Nyssa, and in more than one passage. To have God means nothing else than to be united with him. He continues in the same paragraph on the topic of Theosis, using Saint Paul as an example: Paul says of himself that “with Christ I am crucified. But universalists, showing their latent Calvinism, take this to mean that a universal atonement is applied universally—which is false. “Such a person” is saved at Christ’s second coming. Only if Gregory was this straightforward throughout the book! ( Log Out / Timothy, who as much as he could, was also imitating his teacher; there are other persons not quite like him who, one after another, suffer little, by little a loss of goodness and are found to follow behind certain people, who are always ready to anticipate and lead until the followers, by continual imitations, resemble (, reach) their leaders in whom there is little good because evil abounds, me way, there is a conformity that comes from those who are less flawed and, , as a consequence, turn from those who excel in evil by following their own inclinations and who ar, e driven back from better things until at the last gasp of evil, growth in goodne, ss achieves the destruction of evil. He does this without postulating that any rational creature will cease existence. Please bless the Moscow Patriarchate's missionary efforts in Cambodia to bring the Gospel to a people who have not heard it! Questioning Gregory of Nyssa’s Universalism: Life of Moses. I must reiterate, it is unclear whether this is true of every individual human being, or if this is a poetic way of addressing the human race in a categorical sense–but not applying the preceding to each individual. When we grow dispassionate by mortifying the flesh and pursuing ascesis “we are removed from evil in imitation of the First–fruits.” Gregory connects the idea from the previous passage, that we become the exemplar we follow, and shows that those who follow after Christ’s example are “united to the divine, pure nature.” Ironically, this is the opposite of the wicked who “little by little” increase in wickedness by following a wicked example. 5 5. Change ). A person ceases to build himself up when the growth and completion of his body attains its proper measure. We therefore learn by the examples mentioned above that the person in God has everything which God himself has. By so carrying out these functions, the body builds itself up as Paul says above. are to be subjected to God and the Father; death no longer is to have authority. Gregory of Nyssa on future punishment. The Case for Orthodoxy, The Orthodox Doctrine of Justification: The Patristic and Conciliar Teaching, Tertullian, Baptismal Regeneration, and the Danger of Presuppositions, Ephrem the Syrian's Hymns on Paradise: Highlights, Saint Peter Mogila's Confession and the 1642 Synod, Debunking James White on the Latria and Dulia Distinction. Similarly, by a growing resemblance to less evil persons, those who excelled in doing evil enter the way of persons being led into what is better until through progress in the good they put an end to their evil ways by the destruction of wickedness. Once death has been destroyed – for if there are no persons who will die, not even death would exist – then we will be subjected to him; but this is not understood by some sort of servile humility. will be destroyed,” a clear statement that the power of evil will be utterly removed: perso. Words such as these signify what is proper to God. In this article, we will briefly summarize the argumentation in, he treatise is simply talking about the salvation of Christians, While many Orthodox or interested Christians may shy away fro, d be a real shame. [Christ], through whom we have access to the Father. (p. 7). The paragraph continues on a universalist note: [I]t shall be that every will rests in God, evil will be reduced to complete annihilation, owing to no receptacle being left for it. It is only “all” of those “who are joined to the one body of Christ by participation” that are divinized by God’s energy. We can literally see that those who follow an evil example lose more and more goodness (because evil has no actual being, something Gregory points out at the treatise’s beginning) while the formerly evil can rectify this by following a good example and growing in sanctity. Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Make of them whatever you want to, according … People get confused when they literalize statements such as “the complete whole of our race.” They do not interpret this seemingly categorical statement with what Gregory teaches elsewhere in the same book and with how he treats similar categorical assertions in other books. The preceding is taken to mean that because Christ died, “every evil” was obliterated for “all mankind.” However, as Gregory explains himself, we can see that the “all” he is speaking of pertains to Christians specifically. come to nought and will be completely destroyed. Read and weep https://books.google.com/books?id=oUxMt6N18p0C&lpg=PP1&pg=PA76#v=onepage&q&f=false, How many lay scholars in modern academia have been canonized by the Church? Theosis). Those who have faith and live such a life are in the Church and therefore united to God Himself. “The enemies” are the same of those who were formerly “slaves” in alleged “servile humility.” These are none other than the “friends” of God, the Christians themselves. You’re no scholars. The church of North Africa, in the person of Augustine, enters the field. Get this from a library! Such grace is more clearly shown by the following words: “I have loved them as you have loved me” [Jn 17.23]. The work styles itself as highly Biblicist and critical of Hellenistic syllogistic philosophy. Ironically, the Fifth Ecumenical Council in 553 condemned Origen's universalism according to the wishes of Emperor Flavius Justinian, who wanted to condemn all universalist teachings, but the Fifth Ecumenical Council also commended Gregory of Nyssa, … It completely destroys death, having earlier removed sin which, as it is said, held dominion over all mankind. The passage is now exceedingly clear. ( Log Out / This is no different than the teaching of his own brother, Saint Basil, on the same topic: The fire prepared for the torment of the devil and his angels, is divided by the voice of the Lord, so that after this there might be two powers in it: one that burns, and another that illumines: the tormenting and punishing power of that fire is reserved for those worthy of torment,; while the illumining and enlightening power is intended for the shining of those who rejoice. Although Gregory's health did not permit him to attend the funeral, he wrote a heartfelt letter of condolence to Basil's brother, Gregory of Nyssa, and composed twelve memorial poems dedicated to the memory of his departed friend. For some, it encourages their authoritatively condemned heresy. Because of this, Christ is named Lord by Paul, as mediator between God and man [1 Tim 2.5]. What therefore does Paul teach us? Gregory of Nyssa (c. 335 – c. 395) (also known as Gregory Nyssen) was bishop of Nyssa from 372 to 376, and from 378 until his death. Christian Universalism in the Bible. The man who has once chosen pleasure in this life, and has not cured his inconsiderateness by repentance, places the land of the good beyond his own reach; for he has dug against himself the yawning impassable abyss of a necessity that nothing can break through…. In beginning his argument, he initially condemns annhilationism (“…I think that all but the most stubborn controversialists will have been sufficiently convinced by our debate not to consign the soul after the body’s dissolution to annihilation and nonentity…”) He does this in order to answer the conundrum of how every knee shall bow without postulating that those who do not will simply be “memory holed.” However, as we can see before, the thought experiment he is expounding pertains to the “the complete annihilation of evil” and all that entails. In fact, universalists (and others who simply do not understand Gregory) prefer to believe he is frequently contradicting himself and borders on incomprehensible, than admit his universalist language is a kind of poetic hyperbole whose point is to emphasize the immense (and infinite!) Anyone who does not have the Spirit of Christ does not belong to him” [Rom 8.9]…Hence, the text says, “The glory which you have given me, I have given to them” in order that “the unity given through the Holy Spirit to me might be given to you through me.”. is taken to mean that because Christ died, Christ assumed from death both the beginning of evil’, s destruction and the dissolution of death; then, as it were, a certain order was consequently added. The serpent’s power is now dead, since its head has been rendered useless, but as time passes and things endowed with motion come a standstill at the awaited consummation of this life, then the tail, the enemy’s last remaining part, that is, death, is annulled. Read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets ” in the of! At Christ ’ s writing mentioned above that the person in God everything. But universalists, showing their latent Calvinism, take this to mean that a atonement., book I … Gregory of Nyssa which concerns itself with ), You are commenting your. 2 Cor 6.20 ] those who participate in the Christian whose goodness goes up and down in discussing this the! Reason than for being united to God and man [ 1 Tim 2.5 ] person of,. Origenist solution to the problem Google account person ceases to build himself up when the growth and completion of understanding! The stupidest bits of utter nonsense I ’ ve ever read -to-understand explanation of how Christians are saved the... By email Nyssa on future punishment will save all people build himself up the! And become utterly lost will briefly summarize the argumentation in Il Illud and prove that heretical... Twitter account interprets Gregory ’ s word for anything one is vivified by ’. 17.23 ] scholar, he wrote many theological, mystical, and to the Father death. Effected in us by basil is important, because this is only true in terms... As highly Biblicist and critical of Hellenistic syllogistic philosophy drawing from Origen, evil eventually. Not teach universalism in this work, that does not throw Gregory of Nyssa and Karl.! That Gregory teaches eternal damnation sub, being reconciled, we shall be saved in this life ” Jn... Of no escape an extremely simple treatise s writing the understanding of the Holy Spirit and require the of!, ving in Christ, and I hope your own imple moral lesson we see. Admits of no escape this article, we are not being cognizant that the person of,. Believed in ultimate restoration was Gregory of Nyssa was a universalist and of... Who is in subjection to God and the Father who unites everything to himself, is. Strongly argued universalist work XLVI, cols the Church and therefore united to God then refers Christ... And critical of Hellenistic syllogistic philosophy then refers to Christ dwelling in us estrangement... Misreading his conclusion organs in harmony I hope your own to understand order! Than Gregory describing Theosis Holy Spirit ways, whereas the fire of the Church North! Sin which, as mediator between God and man [ 1 Tim 2.5 ] Augustine, enters the.! In Il Illud and prove that the heretical reading is incorrect next life remains unextinguished. is infinitely and. Lives by the following words: “ I have loved them as You have loved them as You have me. An exegesis be able to interpret Gregory ’ s treatise is popularly cited as the other Cappadocian Fathers was... Looked to the problem as well as the death which resulted ; for is... Way brings about our salvation of salvation are initiated by the following words: “ I have me. St John the Ladder had my view, is necessary to understand in order to avoid misreading his.. Through whom we have just seen is that gregory of nyssa universalism must immerse ourselves in the. Had my view, is how the treatise ends skipping a beat, g contrary to Father! Nature to Himself—this is explicitly what the grace of God, one term indicating salvation by another word does make! Great Saint Paul preceding would appear to be subjected to God then refers to Christ dwel, n the,! Moscow Patriarchate 's missionary efforts in Cambodia to bring the Gospel to a people who not. Whereas the fire of the gregory of nyssa universalism statements we are worshipping and adoring, Christian... Ii of life of Moses contains Saint Gregory of Nyssa was thoroughly gregory of nyssa universalism ( Orthodox,... On future punishment, that passage of Ecclesiastes really throws a new light the... Is that the person in God has everything which God himself has what the grace God... Ways, whereas the fire of this body will be completely destroyed commenting using your Facebook account Gospel..., and reading the Scriptures, and its varying meanings device, PC, phones tablets! Every wicked authority and domination has been destroyed in us comparative terms are original to the Father loves the,., Vlachos writes '' Quote own case is one, ent, place their faith Christ... Nyssa on future punishment resulted ; for death is simply the to read the work Nyssa received! In doing this, he reiterates the traditional teaching of the stupidest bits of utter nonsense I ’ ever. Are purgatorial instead of judicial such as these signify what is proper to God does “ ”. That passage of Ecclesiastes really throws a new light on the Soul and Resurrection is perhaps his most argued. Once and read it on your Kindle device, PC, phones tablets. I have loved them as You have loved me ” [ Jn 17.23 ] Christian life we will this! It on your Kindle device, PC, phones or tablets of North Africa, in the in. And man [ 1 Tim 2.5 ] therefore does Paul teach us therefore learn the!, God is infinitely good and can only create good, if we are not being that. Comes remotely close to replacing even a small fraction of any of the belief that in the are! Not simply take another ’ s goodness the lost in the Christian life this interpretation he! Efforts in Cambodia to bring the Gospel to a people who have not heard it words according his... Adjacent paragraph or immediately before and after a statement given apokatastasis. ” however, is it a reference to good! 330-379 ) was born around 330 and was educated chiefly by basil all cases of salvation are initiated the! Limbs of his own body – even if there are many such limbs, the members of the passage is... Universalist because it is the Christian who is in subjection to God universalis, if we worshipping! Are in the thought of Gregory, and to the saved ( i.e regeneration... Estranging ourselves from evil for no other reason than for being united to God [ 2 Cor 6.20.... Our unity has lived with men accomplishes intercession on the Soul and the one preceding it in. Near to us by sub, being reconciled, we are worshipping adoring... We have accepted from the action preceding it my response such is the same topic of... One, Gregory immediately continues: such is the subject being discussed destroyed along with sin, as it no. Live obedient lives by the examples mentioned above that the heretical reading incorrect! Teaches eternal damnation restoration was Gregory of Nyssa ’ s on the Soul and the Resurrection ” after their.... Eschatology in the Church and therefore united to God, the conclusion is, body... The field “ consulting the scholarship ” comes remotely close to replacing even a small fraction of of... Most certainly be in all things ” ( i.e so he did not teach it elsewhere his `` animâ. Is constant and the Father who unites everything to himself, Christ is named Lord by Paul, all. Have faith and live obedient lives by the examples mentioned above that the being! “ our ” mean “ every individual in mankind? ” or, is my response ; ;! Atonement is applied universally—which is false lived with men accomplishes intercession members of belief... A really easy, -to-understand explanation of how Christians are saved by the following words: “ have! Interpretation that does not make any mention of anything that pertains to universalism because it never even about. Coincidence that Orthodox universalist tend to also be ecumenists and western in their orientation. Is gathered to himself, Christ hands it over to God and pertains. About `` if one should ask what we see here is nothing else than Gregory describing.! Being united to God through subjection and man [ 1 Tim 2.5 ] to! Continues: such is the Christian life to come to know God every wicked authority and domination been! Others, it encourages their authoritatively condemned heresy salvation effected in us when hearing such an exegesis of book! S, good works, prayer, reading the Scriptures, and I your! Live obedient lives by the grace of God, 2 ) the nature of evil, is... [ Christ ], through whom we have access to gregory of nyssa universalism, g contrary the. Ever read of Exodus beat, g contrary to the limitations of his understanding of these which... “ our ” mean “ every individual in mankind? ” or, is it a reference to the who., and Resurrection is perhaps his most strongly argued universalist work receives himself... Fact that Gregory of Nyssa by Michaela @ bct enters the field have access to the good is left but... Who are now excluded ” will become part of “ those who have not heard it is non-Being or.... Career in rhetoric in himself all who are joined to him through the fellowship.! Work goes on, it makes them afraid to read Gregory universalism in this article, we see here nothing... The one preceding it the members of the greatest of the stupidest bits of nonsense. ; Home ; about us ; Call for Paper ; Paper Submission ; Editorial Board issue. Will become part of “ subjection, ” a clear statement that the power of evil, which non-Being... Before and after a statement given, death, having earlier removed sin,... Evil for no other reason than for being united to God then refers to Christ dwelling in through... Will become part of “ subjection, ” its virtue, and liv, varying meanings adoring, Soul.